Expulsion for “Presence”: Melbourne University’s Strict Interpretation of Protest Rules

In a strict interpretation of its protest rules, the University of Melbourne is recommending expulsion for a student whose “presence” at a pro-Palestine office occupation last October was deemed a violation, even without direct involvement in alleged misconduct. Two students face expulsion and two suspension, marking a potential first for such severe disciplinary actions against pro-Palestine activists in Australia since the recent wave of demonstrations. The students are preparing to appeal.
The disciplinary action stems from an incident where around 20 individuals occupied an academic’s office for about 90 minutes. Their goal was to urge the university to end its partnerships with Israeli universities, aligning with the global boycott, divestment, and sanctions movement. Footage distributed on social media showed protesters entering the office with their faces covered.
The university has alleged harassment and intimidation of staff, along with property damage, including placing signs and stickers on university items and writing on personal belongings. The students, however, assert that their demonstration was peaceful and politically motivated, and that they made efforts to minimize disruption by informing those present and offering to turn down music.
This specific recommendation highlights the controversial nature of the university’s recently implemented anti-protest policies, which have been labeled “repressive” and “authoritarian” by critics, including human rights organizations. While the university declines to comment on individual cases, it emphasizes its adherence to disciplinary processes and the students’ right to appeal.